A Complacency Safety Talk From the Cockpit: Why Good People Stop Checking
Here is a question I ask my crew to think about before every flight, and I’ll ask you the same one: today, what could lead a smart, well-trained person to make a bad decision?
Notice I said smart and well trained. We don’t hire stupid people. Your crews badge in with good intentions, the right training and the right equipment. And yet experienced people still get hurt on routine jobs. That is complacency, the silent killer of workplace safety, quality and productivity. When you’ve done a job a thousand times, it turns into unconscious competence, and that is dangerous in a hurt-me, kill-me environment.
Experience Breeds Complacency
I flew the A-10 Warthog with the 18th Tactical Fighter Squadron at Eielson AFB in Alaska. Today I fly as an international captain for a major airline based in Atlanta, Georgia, on the Airbus A350. In both cockpits, the most experienced pilots still run a checklist on every flight. Not because they forgot how to fly. Because experience breeds complacency, and the checklist is how we fight it.
I learned that personally in Alaska. On a training mission, youthful exuberance and over-confidence brought me closer to the ground than I ever want to be again. Skill was not the problem. Confidence was. You know what experience is? It’s that thing you get after you need it.
The Lesson That Cost Me My Brother
The hardest lesson I ever learned about complacency in safety cost me my brother Johnny. I lost him in an aviation accident that I believe my own errant work behavior and failed leadership contributed to. Knowing the procedure is one thing. Doing it every time, on the day you are rushed, is something else. Johnny followed my deeds, my work behavior, not so much my words.
That is why I talk so much about the size of the shadow you cast. Apprentices learn how it’s done from the classroom binder. They learn the way it’s done from you.
“Your propeller story was one of the most powerful messages I’ve heard. I’ll put that lesson in my tool kit going forward.”
C.C., Nuclear Programs Manager, Siemens Energy (INPO session)
How Complacency Creeps In
Fighting complacency in safety starts with seeing how it grows. It almost always looks like this:
- A shortcut works. Nothing bad happens, and the job gets done faster.
- It gets rewarded. The schedule is happy, and nobody asks how.
- Others watch. Newer people see a respected veteran do it and assume it’s fine.
- Silence makes it normal. Nobody says anything, and silence is consent.
- Then the day comes when it isn’t fine.
Schedule pressure, ego and previous success drive most of it. And the decision usually happens in a moment, in an instant.
A 5-Minute Complacency Toolbox Talk Your Crews Can Use
Feel free to print this and use it at your next toolbox talk or pre-job brief.
Minute 1: Ask the question. “Today, what could lead a smart, well-trained person on this crew to make a bad decision?” Then stay quiet. The best answers come after the silence that feels too long.
Minute 2: Name the routine job. Pick one task the crew does so often they could do it in their sleep. That is where complacency lives.
Minute 3: Walk it like the first time. Talk through that task step by step, as if a brand new hire were watching. Ask: “Which step has drifted? Which check do we do from memory?”
Minute 4: Practice the words. Have two people say it out loud: “Stop. I’m not comfortable with this. Let’s take a look.” The answer from the lead is: “Thank you. Show me.”
Minute 5: Make one commitment. Each person names one check they will do every single time this week, even when they’re rushed. Bring it back up at the next talk.
Closing line for the leader: “Spend a few seconds of your life doing it right, because you can lose your life in a few seconds doing it wrong.”
Where Leaders Fit
Crews don’t fight complacency because a poster tells them to. They fight it when they see their foreman, their superintendent and their plant manager run the check on the day they’re behind schedule. What they see you do today will influence how they do it tomorrow.
If you want more ideas for an all hands, here are my safety stand-down ideas your crews will remember. And if you’d like a complacency safety talk delivered live to your people, take a look at my workplace safety keynote for conferences and stand-downs. Every keynote is built around your crews and your hazards. You can check my availability here or call 770-356-6240.
Fly safe,
Odie


